A reflection on The Other Side of the Tracks by Elizabeth Rouble Hill
Four months ago, I began writing about Toronto while discovering it.
I have written about museums, neighbourhoods, and some of the people who give this city its character. Each story has offered another entrance. Sometimes, though, I wonder whether my words resemble notices pasted on walls: a name, a date, something worth stopping to see.
What happens behind those walls? What is the story behind the story?
I am beginning to understand that knowing a city takes more than visits and interviews. It also means listening to people who walked its streets before us and found the courage to put their thoughts on paper. Their memories hold rooms we cannot otherwise enter.
One of those people is a woman born in 1942. Her name is Elizabeth.
In Elizabeth Rouble Hill’s memoir, The Other Side of the Tracks, Toronto comes into view from a rented house on Maria Street, near the Runnymede Road underpass. Trains shake the rooms and scatter soot over the washing.
I imagine writing about that street from the pavement. I might describe the brick houses, explain the railway’s importance, and look for an old photograph. Hill tells me something I would never learn by looking: when the railway workers went on strike, her family could not sleep.
The trains had stopped. The silence kept them awake.
How much of belonging begins this way? A sound enters our sleep, becomes part of the household, and stays with us long after we leave.
Hill’s childhood map follows familiar names: St. Clair Avenue, Dundas Street, High Park, Annette Street. As I read her, I begin to picture what once happened along streets I know by name.
Elizabeth Hill at about two years old, circa 1944, in front of the railway tracks across from her family’s home on Maria Street.
Near Keele and St. Clair, the Ontario Stockyards filled the air with the smell of livestock. Occasionally, an escaped animal interrupted traffic. The stockyards closed in 1993; in Hill’s recollections, frightened animals still stop traffic as children watch.
She recalls returning to St. Clair Avenue Public School and finding an empty lot and the exposed remains of its furnace. But she remembers the coloured glass, milk sometimes warm in its bottle, stockings damp from leaky boots, and the library where she chose her books.
The building has gone. She can still take us inside.
Then comes an evening at the O’Keefe Centre, the theatre now known as Meridian Hall. Hill goes to see My Fair Lady.
Earlier, she has been helping her carpenter father on a building job. For the evening, she puts on a yellow dress, white gloves, and borrowed high heels. There is a live orchestra. The stage opens onto beautiful clothes, music, and possibility. She sees something of herself in Eliza.
Afterwards, she lingers with her boyfriend, repeating the songs. Eventually, she returns to the sleeping house and pulls the kitchen light cord.
Cockroaches scatter.
She rolls up her programme to strike them, then stops. She wants to keep it clean, a souvenir. The insects’ little legs seem to move to the rhythm of “The Rain in Spain.”
By then, I have stopped observing her Toronto from a distance. I am standing in the kitchen, reluctant to let the evening end.
Elizabeth Hill at age 17, in a high school photograph from Western Tech.
I think of Midnight in Paris, of the pleasure of following a familiar street into another time. Hill’s book offers its own quiet passage. Somewhere between the railway chalk and the theatre programme, we cross over. We begin to know what things cost, what a girl hopes for, what she feels embarrassed about.
From there, today’s Toronto looks different.
Her father builds houses but cannot afford one. Her parents live in their rented home for twenty-seven years, then have to leave when the landlord decides to sell. Reading this, I imagine passing those houses again and wondering who repaired their windows, who paid the rent, and who hoped to stay.
Hill’s prose is strongest when these questions grow out of ordinary things: a workshop, a sheet, a programme she cannot bring herself to stain. Through them, I begin to feel the lives behind the walls.
I keep returning to her diary. She addressed her entries to Elizabeth-of-the-Future, recording feelings she wanted her older self to remember.
For a moment, I imagine standing beside the young Elizabeth as she looks towards that other woman, the one who will eventually write this book. Years later, the older Elizabeth opens the notebook. The girl has left something there for her.
Reading it now, we find something waiting for us, too: a way into her Toronto, and another way of seeing our own.
YF, October 16, 2026
Note: This narrative draws on Elizabeth Rouble Hill’s The Other Side of the Tracks: Growing Up in Toronto in the Shadow of the Great Depression and offers a brief reflection on the book.
If you’d like to read Elizabeth’s book, please visit the link below:
The Story Only You Can Tell Is there a memory or life experience you’ve always wanted to put into words? In QAF Story Lab, I’ll help you turn it into a short story, with personal feedback along the way. With each writer’s permission, we’ll also select stories to publish for our audience of more than 2,000 readers. If you’re interested, click the button below to learn more.